Ad astra per aspera... Fikri hür, vicdanı hür, irfanı hür, nesiller ...
"Bizge vacip olğan – soñki nefeske qadar millet ve yurt oğrunda ğayrettir." İsmail Bey Gaspıralı

27 Ocak 2018 Cumartesi

On interference, collegiality and co-authorship: Peer review of journal articles in management and organization studies

On interference, collegiality and co-authorship: Peer review of journal articles in management and organization studies

Management and organization studies commentary on how authors experience peer review of journal papers suggests that it can be an overly interventionist process which reduces the originality and coherence of eventual publications. In the literature on co-authorship, this argument is reversed. Here, free riders who do not contribute fully to research collaborations and the practice of gift authorships are problematized, and it is argued that everyone involved in writing a published paper should be rewarded with co-authorship. In this article, qualitative interviews with 12 management and organization studies academics see respondents describing peer review as a transaction during which reviewers – and editors – actually co-author published papers. But their perspectives on this vary with the subject position from which they are speaking. When they speak as reviewers or editors, this co-authorship is depicted as a collegiate gift, a professional obligation or a process where authors might over-rely on reviewers’ generosity. When they speak as authors or their proxies, it is characterized as reproducing disciplinary orthodoxy and ethnocentric exclusion, perpetuating disciplinary cliques, creating disorganized papers and constituting excessive interference with authorial privilege. These various perspectives on peer review deserve more attention in our empirical studies of academic labour. They also suggest we should reflect more on when, how and why we collaborate in our research and on how much we should recognize additional co-authors on (or resist their input into) ‘our’ work.
Keywords Co-authorshipjournal papersmanagement and organization studiespeer review
http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1350508417703472

First Published January 11, 2018 Research Article
Share:

0 yorum:

Yorum Gönder

En Popüler Yayınlar

Total Pageviews


"Tatmin eden övgü ve sövgü sizin olsun, idrâk veren bilgi bize yeter." Prof. Dr. İhsan Fazlıoğlu
"Erdemlerin en büyüğü bilimdir. İnsanlar erdem sahibi olmazsa, şehir ve yöneticiler de erdemli olmaz."
Farabi, Erdemli Şehir

"Taşköprülüzâde, 'İlim aklın ibadetidir' diyor. Biz ibadetimizi yapacağız, aklımızı kullanacağız, yola çıkacağız ve düşüneceğiz"
Prof. Dr. İhsan Fazlıoğlu

Blog Archive

ÖĞRENMEYİ SEVMEK

"Bilgiye sahip olarak doğmuş birisi değilim. Yalnızca öğrenmeyi ve öğretmeyi seviyorum."
Konfüçyüs

"Bilgi, ahlaki hareketten kalan şeydir."
Nurettin Topçu

Translate

ŞEHİTLERE VEFA!

ŞEHİTLERE VEFA!
"Bebem anasız büyür, Vatansız büyüyemez!" Nene Hatun

Link list 3

Blog Archive

Rusça-Türkçe Çevİrİ Hİzmetlerİ